Article links:
Bookmark and Share

Utilising basic soil data for the sustainable management of upland soils in Vietnam and Australia

Project ID

SMCN/2002/085

Project Country

Commissioned Organisation

Department of Natural Resources and Water, Australia

Project Leader

Dr Philip Moody

Email

Phil.Moody@derm.qld.gov.au

Phone: 

07 3170 5706

Fax: 

07 3170 5801

Collaborating Institutions

Institute of Agricultural Sciences of South Vietnam, Department of Soils and Fertilisers, Vietnam
National Institute for Soils and Fertilisers, Department of Land Use Research, Vietnam
World Vision of Vietnam, Bac Binh Area Development Program, Vietnam

Project Budget

$435,845.00

Start Date

01/01/2004

Finish Date

31/12/2006

Extension Start Date

01/07/2007

Extension Finish Date

31/12/2007

ACIAR Research Program Manager

Dr Gamini Keerthisinghe

Overview Objectives

The project sought to provide a decision support framework that allowed basic soil information to be interpreted in terms of soil constraints to productivity and to be synthesised into management strategies appropriate for maintaining the long-term productivity of upland soils. This would enable results obtained in a site-specific context to be applied at the provincial/catchment scale, through the use of existing geo-coded soil survey data and SCAMP.

Project Background and Objectives

Traditional subsistence agricultural systems based on slash-and-burn practices have degraded soils in upland areas of Vietnam's central highlands. Extensive deforestation and land clearing have resulted, leading to erosion and soil fertility declines. Ethnic minorities who have practised this style of agriculture have high levels of poverty, and little knowledge of other agricultural practices. The Vietnamese Government has encouraged these minorities to settle in villages and undertake permanent agricultural production in surrounding areas. Soil productivity in these areas remains low, with knowledge of practices to ensure long-term sustainability negligible. Constraints to productivity are numerous and include nutrient deficiencies and toxicities in soils, and soil compaction.

A variety of soil information has been collected, mainly for soil classification purposes. Despite this information being available little has been made of the data in terms of assessing soil productivity constraints. Scientists have developed a simple Soil Constraints and Management Package ('SCAMP') that uses measures and properties (texture, colour, etc) of collected soil, or soil examined in the field, to identify constraints and indicates appropriate management strategies. Scaling this up for interpretation of soil constraints and strategies to ameliorate or manage these at the village level is needed to help develop improved practices.

Progress Reports (Year 1, 2, 3 etc)

Year 1

Key activities undertaken since the commencement of the project include a project inception meeting in Gia Lai Province, Vietnam, in May 2004, a project workshop at Ingham, Queensland, in August 2004, and a project planning visit to Vietnam by the Australian project leader in November 2004.

Objective A1
Two sites have been selected in Gia Lai Province for detailed assessment of management strategies for overcoming soil constraints to productivity. The Ferralsol site is at Ia Kha village, near Pleiku, while the Acrisol site is at An Thanh village in Dak Po District. Initial soil samples to 30 cm have been taken from each block of the proposed trials. These samples will be analysed for pH, EC and fertility status to allow selection of appropriate treatments. The constraints of both sites have been assessed using SCAMP and are: Ferralsol: P fixation, Al toxicity (?), N and P deficiency, low K reserves (?), low ECEC (?), low organic C (?); Acrisol: N and P (?) deficiency, compaction, low infiltration rate, waterlogging, hard-setting (?) Where the constraint is designated (?), confirmation will depend on the results of outstanding analyses.

At the November planning meeting, a sampling protocol was sorted out for the proposed Ferralsol and Acrisol surveys. Ferralsols on different parent materials will be sampled in 3 areas of differing elevation and rainfall in Gia Lai Province. Soil properties will be characterised and SCAMP used to define constraints, allowing assessment of the variability required in management practices across Ferralsols. A similar assessment will be made of variation in the management of Acrisols of An Thanh village, Dak Po District, using recent NISF soil survey data.

The proposed monitoring sites of the World Vision project CTE/2000/165 were visited and their constraints assessed using SCAMP. Based on this assessment, decisions are being made by the CTE/2000/165 project team on appropriate treatments (one of the treatments will be 'farmer practice') at each site.

Objective A3
Following the Ingham workshop (where SCAMP was applied to several soils in the Herbert catchment), further soil properties (soil structure, soil consistence, hard setting tendency, low soil organic C, permeability class, drainage class) have been added to SCAMP to increase its comprehensiveness. To facilitate the adoption of SCAMP, it is proposed that 3 application 'levels' will be developed: Level 1 based on field observations only, Level 2 based on field observations and field measurements, and Level 3 incorporating Level 2 measurements plus lab measurements. A manual describing the levels is in preparation.

Objective B1
Queries have been made of an Access database containing SCAMP categories for several soil constraints and geo-coded soil survey data for the Herbert catchment (north Queensland), and a series of risk and constraint maps have been produced. These maps have validated the queries and data sorting protocols that have been developed in this project to link geo-coded data and SCAMP attributes. Presented below is the soil acidification risk map indicating the number of years under sugar cane cropping required to reduce soil pHwater to 4.5. It is based on the Net Acid Addition Rate of the sugarcane cropping system, the current soil pH and the pH buffer capacity of the soil.

Year 2

Key results and activities of 2005 include:
Vietnam: Objectives A1.3, A2.1- Maize biomass and grain yield responses were obtained on a Ferralsol soil to Tithonia residue addition (at 3 tonnes/ha) and bentonite addition (5 tonnes/ha), and these yields exceeded those obtained at the recommended rate of NPK fertiliser addition. It appears that increased productivity from these treatments is probably associated with increased CEC (and therefore increased capacity for retention of nutrient cations) and improved availability of phosphorus when added in organic form, but confirmation of these causes will depend on completion of soil and plant analyses.

On an Acrisol soil, maize biomass and grain yields were higher where bentonite (5 tonnes/ha) or a soil conditioner that increased soil water holding capacity (at 20 kg/ha) had been applied than where the recommended rate of NPK fertiliser had been applied. The reasons for these differential responses will be clarified when soil and plant analyses are completed, but it is suggested that improved soil moisture status may be the primary cause.

The results from these two sites indicate that different management strategies are required on different soil types to overcome soil constraints to productivity.

Objective A1.1-The transect of Ferralsol soils in Gia Lai has revealed the existence of soils with minimal surface charge ('geric' soils according to the FAO soil classification system). These soils present a challenge to nutrient management because of their inability to retain cation and anion nutrients for plant growth. Similar soils occur in tropical Australia. Development of appropriate fertiliser management strategies for these soils will be investigated in a Master's Degree program which will be undertaken by one of the Vietnamese project staff following the award of a John Allwright Fellowship for study in 2006-2007.

Australia: Objective A3.1- A draft SCAMP manual has been produced detailing the measurement, interpretation and management implications of key soil properties grouped into categories of water and climate constraints, soil pH and acidity constraints, cation constraints, clay fraction constraints, landscape constraints, and soil structural constraints. This manual will be the basis of the training workshop to be held for agricultural extensionists in Vietnam.

Objective B1.2-The inclusion of a simple soil water partitioning model into SCAMP has allowed identification of the major pathway of water movement (runoff, ponding or drainage) for any soil based on its drainage and permeability ratings. This information has been used to produce a map of the major pathways of water movement in soils of the Wet Tropical Coast of Queensland (see Figure 1). This output will be enhanced by further programming that will link this dominant water movement pathway with timing and placement method of fertiliser application to assess the risk of off-site nutrient movement and denitrification.

Year 3

Key results and activities of 2006 include:
Vietnam: Objectives A1.3, A2.1- In the 2006 growing season, a second maize crop was grown on the Ferralsol site at Ia Kha. Maximum grain yield (4.7 T/ha) was obtained in the treatment where Tithonia residues at the rate of 1T/ha were mixed through the planting row soil to a depth of 10 cm (1/3 total area) and additional NPK fertiliser was applied to meet the recommendation of 115N 42P 100K. It is likely that the success of this treatment was due to the correction of excessive soil acidity (soil pH was increased) and the gradual release of N and P from the plant residues better matching crop demand than in treatments where inorganic fertiliser was applied. This treatment also provided the highest gross margin of VND 7.1 M/ha.

A maize field experiment was also carried out on an Acrisol soil in Dak Po at a site (Tan An village) different from where the 2005 Acrisol experiment was undertaken. The highest grain yield (5.3 T/ha) was obtained where the fertiliser recommendation (92N 29P 75K) had been applied together with 10 T/ha bentonite mixed through the planting row soil to a depth of 10 cm (1/3 total area) to increase CEC and water holding capacity. However, the maximum gross margin (VND 9.2 M/ha) was obtained from the treatment receiving the fertiliser recommendation and where mounding and application of roots and stems of Peuraria and Mucuna at 500 kg/ha had been used to improve soil structure and drainage. The grain yield from this treatment (5.2 T/ha) was not much less than the former treatment. These results suggest that drainage and soil physical characteristics are constraints to productivity for this soil.

The results from the field trials support the conclusion of the previous year's trials that soil-specific management practices are needed for sustainable productivity.

Objective A1.1- Field data and lab analyses for the soils collected during the Ferralsol transect and the Acrisol soil survey have been input into the SCAMP database and constraints and management strategies identified as outputs. Data summary reports and SCAMP constraints reports have been produced for each of the 14 Ferralsol and 16 Acrisol sites.

Australia: Objective A3.1- A second draft of the SCAMP Field and Laboratory Handbook has been prepared. Compared to the first draft it contains: more interpretive information on the Emerson dispersion test; a table using structure, texture, mottling and colour to assist in the allocation of drainage and permeability ratings. These modifications have not yet been translated into Vietnamese, and the first draft (in Vietnamese) has been the basis of the training workshops held for agricultural extensionists in Vietnam.

Objective B1.2- A major enhancement to SCAMP has been the development of the 'Safegauge for Nutrients' decision support system (DSS). This DSS will import basic soil information from the SCAMP database to allocate a qualitative risk of off-site nitrogen and phosphorus movement as a result of fertiliser practices. The DSS allows the user (extensionist, farmer) to assess the effects of different fertiliser management scenarios (time of application, method of application, rate of application, fertiliser form) on risk. Following anticipated completion by mid 2007, the SCAMP-Safegauge DSS will be trialled by a group of Queensland canegrowers to assess its usefulness as an awareness/education package for the Australian sugar industry.

Project Outcomes

Although a soils map at 1:100,000 scale was available for Gia Lai Province, Vietnam, little use had been made of this information either to assess soil constraints to productivity at regional scale or to extrapolate findings from site-specific field experiments to other areas. SCAMP was introduced to facilitate the use of existing soils information for making informed decisions about sustainable soil management. Simple soil measurements and properties (e.g. texture, colour, drainage rating and soil pH) were entered into the SCAMP Access database and specific criteria in look-up tables were used to identify intrinsic soil constraints to long-term productivity.

Depending on the constraints identified for a soil, a report is derived from the SCAMP database indicating appropriate strategies for managing the constraints. Where geo-referenced soil survey data are available, the SCAMP Access database has been used to assign specific attributes to individual soil types, and because the database interfaces with Geographic Information Systems (GIS) such as MapInfo and ARCGIS, maps of constraints or specific soil attributes can be produced.

To demonstrate the ability of SCAMP to identify soil constraints at plot scale, the package was applied to soil data sets from the two major soil types (Ferralsols and Acrisols) of Gia Lai Province. Phosphorus (P) fixation, aluminium toxicity and low cation exchange capacity (CEC) were identified as common constraints to productivity on Ferralsols, and low plant available water capacity, compaction and low potassium (K) status as common constraints to productivity on Acrisols. Field experiments were undertaken on a Ferralsol site (two cropping seasons: 2005 and 2006) and two Acrisols (single sites in 2005 and 2006) to assess management strategies for minimising these constraints in the presence of adequate N, P, and K fertiliser.

In both years, maize (Zea mays) yields from the Ferralsol were increased by applying a plant amendment (Tithonia diversifolia) (selected to increase soil pH and decrease P fixation) and high activity clay (selected to increase CEC). Water-soluble P fertiliser recovery was increased in this high P-fixing soil by placing the fertiliser in a sub-surface band. In economic terms, the Tithonia treatments consistently produced the highest benefit/cost ratios (1.3 in 2005; 3.2 in 2006). For the Acrisol in 2006, maize was grown in mounded rows (to improve drainage) and yields were maximised by applying a super-absorbent material (selected to increase soil water holding capacity), high activity clay (selected to increase the low CEC of this soil) or incorporating green manure residues into the crop mound. The benefit/cost ratios obtained for these treatments were 4.1, 2.9 and 5.2 respectively.

To demonstrate the usefulness of SCAMP on a catchment/regional scale, maps identifying areas of low pH, high acidification hazard and low CEC were produced for the Herbert River catchment, Queensland. Maps were also produced for the Wet Tropics of north Queensland identifying the predominant pathway of off-site nutrient movement. The catchment management agency used this information to identify high-risk areas where awareness programs could help landholders to improve fertiliser management practices.

The SCAMP manual and supporting resource materials were translated into Vietnamese. Subsequently several SCAMP training courses were held for provincial and district extensionists and for project staff and leaders of World Vision agricultural development projects.

Location

There are no project locations defined for this project.