Article links:
Bookmark and Share

Integrated control of powdery mildew and other disease, weed and insect problems in squash in Tonga and Australia

Project ID

PC/2003/046

Project Country

Commissioned Organisation

University of Sydney, Faculty of Agriculture Food and Natural Resources, Australia

Project Leader

Associate Professor Robyn McConchie

Email

r.mcconchie@usyd.edu.au

Phone: 

0293518536 or

Fax: 

0293518562 or 02 9351 4172

Collaborating Institutions

Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Food, Tonga
Secretariat of the Pacific Community, Fiji

Project Budget

$555,469.00

Start Date

01/01/2005

Finish Date

30/06/2008

Extension Start Date

01/04/2010

Extension Finish Date

31/12/2010

ACIAR Research Program Manager

Dr Richard Markham

Overview Objectives

Foster the sustainability of the Tonga squash industry through improvements to integrated disease, pest and weed management, specifically to improve field-based crop protection and market quality of squash within a systems framework addressing:
powdery mildew,
silverleaf whitefly,
virus management,
weed management, and
grower uptake and market implications.

Project Background and Objectives

Agriculture is a vital contributor to the economy of Tonga. It is the leading employer, foreign exchange earner and is essential to food security. The leading agricultural export is squash, earning $10.8 million in 2002. Squash is quick and easy to grow with a clear market in exports to Japan. In recent times other export industries in the agriculture sector have suffered due to pest and disease problems, making squash even more vital. These disease and pest problems are now beginning to reach threatening levels in the squash sector too. Controls against pests and diseases have been less effective. In turn this has increased pesticide usage resulting in pesticide resistance emerging. The use of pesticides also has implications for Tonga's water supply which is particularly vulnerable to water borne pollutants. The prevalence of diseases and pests has reduced the industry by close to two-thirds, from 2000 active farmers in 1987 to an estimated 550 in 2003.

Powdery mildew is the main disease. Outbreaks defoliate crops, in turn making plants more vulnerable to silver leaf white fly, other viruses and weeds. Current fungicides against powdery mildew are unreliable with increasing resistance reported. Past ACIAR research has demonstrated the value of integrated approaches to controlling powdery mildew which are applicable to Tongan conditions. These, along with pest controls targeting white fly and disease controls against viruses found in squash, have the potential to significantly rehabilitate the industry. The sustainability of the Tongan squash industry is being addressed through improvements to integrated disease, pest and weed management, specifically to improve field-based crop protection and market quality of squash within a systems framework.

Progress Reports (Year 1, 2, 3 etc)

Year 1

Tonga
A field investigation into control of powdery mildew using fungicides, generally regarded as safe (GRAS) chemicals and inducers of natural resistance was conducted this season from July to October 2005. Powdery mildew severity was relatively mild this season. The most effective fungicide in this trial was Talius (both high and low rates) followed by Punch+Afugan, Sulphur, JMS stylet oil, Actigard and the Control (untreated). Exportable yield in t/ha was highest in Talius treatments with 17.21 (low rate), 15.30(high rate), 13.29 (Punch+Afugan, 12.71 (Rubigan), 12.20 (Sulphur), 11.29 (Actigard), 11.01 (JMS stylet oil) and 10.96 (Control). Sugar content was highest in the Punch+Afugan replicates with 9.81%, Actigard (9.64%), Rubigan (9.40%), JMS stylet oil (9.39%), Talius[high (9.15%)], Sulphur (9.08%), Control (8.70%) and the lowest sugar content was recorded in Talius [low(8.61%)].
Australia
An objective powdery mildew screening procedure was developed using a scanning program to assess % severity. Six cultivars of squash : Kabocha SPS8682, Kabocha SPS3742, Kabocha Amali Delica 2643R3KQJ, Kabocha SPS7764, Kabocha SPS8702, Hybrid Japanese Kurijiman F1were screened for resistance to powdery mildew. All were susceptible with no evidence of partial resistance. In glasshouse trials, whole leaf and detached leaf screening of GRAS and defence elicitors was conducted for control of powdery mildew prior to conducting a field trial. Milsana, Thiovit, Silica, an organic oil product GC3, an oil product Biocover, Actigard, and Ti Tree oil, were used and the best treatments selected for use in a field trial in late 2005. In separate trials optimum concentrations of Milsana and silica for PM control was determined. Milsana and Thiovit were significantly better at controlling powdery mildew in the preliminary trials. For the field trial, an integrated approach was developed in testing efficacy of both Milsana and Thiovit against conventional fungicide treatments. Treatments were: Milsana, Thiovit, Amistar, alternate Milsana + Thiovit, alternate Thiovit + Amistar, alternate Milsana + Thiovit + Amistar, Water and Surfactant, and Commercial Practice. The trial was completed in March 2006 and is currently being analysed.

Year 2

Aim
To improve field-based crop protection and market quality of squash within a systems framework addressing a) Powdery Mildew, b) silver leaf whitefly, c) virus management, d) weed management and e) grower uptake and market implications.

Objectives
1. Development of integrated field management strategies for control of Powdery Mildew and other fungal diseases.
2. Investigation of sustainable cultural, biological and chemical control strategies to Silver leaf Whitefly infestations
3. Identification and control of the major virus diseases of Kabocha squash
4. Development of effective approaches to suppressing weeds that compete with and limit crop production and profitability for farmers in cropping.
5. Optimization of technological adoption and extension through use of on-farm trials and stakeholder workshops and increase awareness of market implications

Due to the retirement of Dr Pita Taufatofua, Dr Villami Manu, Head of Vaini Research Station, has taken over as Team Leader of the Tongan MAFF research team. In contrast to 2005 when a government strike interrupted trials, the team members have made significant progress in meeting the project objectives in 2006.
Both 2005 and 2006 trials in Tonga and Australia have shown that replacement of fungicides with Generally Regarded as Safe (GRAS) chemicals is just as effective in controlling Powdery Mildew as using traditional fungicides alone. The results indicate that environmentally friendly chemicals can be used in controlling powdery mildew without compromising control. Preliminary testing for fungicide resistance by Powdery Mildew suggests there is no resistance to the current suite of fungicides used in Tonga, but this needs to be verified by further testing with isolates from a greater geographical range.

Weed species and other cucurbit crops were screened as potential alternative hosts for viruses. ELISA tests found that Sonchus oleraceus and Chamaesyce sp. were alternative hosts for ZYMV and WMV. The results indicate that weed control around squash plantations is an important aspect of virus control. Further screening for alternative hosts will be conducted in 2007, as will testing for virus transmission via seed.

A survey of weed species and % cover during succession after ploughing was conducted. An early weed coloniser was Commelina sp. however within 3 weeks Macuna seeds had germinated and become the dominant leafy cover. Trials using Macuna pruriens as a cover crop during the fallow season were also begun in 2006. In July 2007, squash will be either planted through the herbicided Macuna or planted after the Macuna cover crop is ploughed in. Apart from the benefits of weed control, Macuna is expected to increase nitrogen levels in the soil, reducing the input of inorganic fertilizer.

Colonies of the introduced Silver Leaf Whitefly parasitoid Erotmocerus hayati died during early 2006. The parasitoid will be re-introduced from Brisbane in early 2007. Evaluation of safer insecticides that are compatible with IPM, was conducted in 2006. All were effective against SLWF, however data are yet to be analysed.

Ms Sela Tupouniau, the MAFF Plant Pathologist took up a JAF fellowship in January 2007 to study for her PhD. at the University of Sydney.

Year 3

Under the leadership of Dr Viliami Manu, Head of Vaini Research Station, the Tongan MAFF research team made significant progress in meeting objectives in 2007. The 2007 field trial for controlling powdery mildew on squash using fungicides suggests there is no resistance to currently available fungicides in Tonga. Rotational use of the fungicides is important to prevent resistance development in powdery mildew strains.
The GRAS chemicals tested in Tonga and Australia show consistent effectiveness for the control of powdery mildew of squash. A recommendation will be made on the cost to the Tongan and Australian markets on incorporating GRAS chemicals into the spray schedule, reducing the reliance on fungicides.
A study on the powdery mildew populations in squash in Tonga is underway by Ms Tupouniua as part of her PhD study program. Samples of squash powdery mildew are being tested for their sensitivity against different fungicides along with a microscopic study for taxonomic identification.
Field evaluation of insecticides to control Silverleaf Whitefly was not conclusive because of very low infestation in squash during the experimental season (August 2007). An experiment on biological control of Silverleaf Whitefly in tomato is underway in controlled conditions with the introduced parasite of Eretmocerus hayati from Brisbane CSIRO. Methods for screening alternative hosts of viruses affecting squash production were demonstrated to MAFF personnel and the tests are being conducted.
The experiments for the effectiveness of the cover crop of Macuna pruriens that began in 2006 and again in 2007 has been shown to be beneficial in controlling weed population as well increasing economic returns from squash cultivation.
A survey was conducted in 2007 in squash growing areas for prevalence of insect pest and diseases and weed infestation. Good rainfall and a cool climate in 2007 resulted in increased production of squash, through increased fruit set, despite significant powdery mildew infestation during the season. The same climatic conditions reduced the population of Silverleaf Whitefly, and as a result, lowered the level of infection by virus.

Year 4

In April 2008 a review of the project PC(then HORT)/2003/046, Integrated control of Powdery mildew and other disease, weed and insect problems in squash in Tonga and Australia, was undertaken and a report submitted to ACIAR. The review indicated that the project has performed well against most objectives, activities, milestones and outputs and the project team is to be congratulated on the work to date. Despite some minor setbacks and issues, significant progress had been made towards the aims and objectives.
For Powdery mildew, it was demonstrated, in Australia and Tonga, that generally regarded as safe (GRAS) chemicals such as Stylet Oil and Milsana could be effectively incorporated into commercial spray programs, thereby reducing the number of less-environmentally friendly fungicides applied. On this basis, recommended spray regimes have been developed. In addition, fungicide resistance to commonly used commercial powdery mildew fungicides has been detected in powdery mildew isolates from Tonga.
For Silverleaf whitefly (SLW), the parasitoid, Eretmocerus hayati, has been introduced from the Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) in Australia and released in Tonga. Two SLW insecticides that are compatible with integrated pest management (IPM) approaches, Chess and Applaud, have been identified for inclusion in an IPM strategy.
Two major potyviruses associated with virus diseases in squash in Tonga have been identified, along with a range of weed hosts and vectors.
To improve weed management, Mucuna has been demonstrated as a weed control technique, for use both pre-planting and as an inter-row cover crop.
In the area of technology transfer and extension, field days, workshops and IPM training workshops were held for growers and technical staff. Field surveys of powdery mildew and SLW distribution in commercial crops were completed.
Additional activities were undertaken, including studies on: cultivar resistance to powdery mildew, chemical resistance to powdery mildew strains, virus on seed transmissibility and planting directly into mulches.
Capacity building activities have included visits of staff of the Tongan Ministry of Agriculture and Food, Forests and Fisheries (MAFFF) to Australia for training, in-country workshops, transfer of technical and scientific skills (e.g. trial design and analysis, ELISA) and formal training through the John Allwright Fellowship Scheme.
While the project has achieved many of the intended milestones and outcomes, there are three major deficiencies that have the potential to severely restrict the project's impact: commercial recommendations have not been formally developed, nor have the elements, plus agronomy, been included in an integrated crop management package; demonstration and dissemination of these recommendations has not occurred; and robust economic analysis of these recommendation has not been carried out - i.e. demonstration that these recommendations are not only effective but also cost-effective.
The review team recommended an extension phase of the project to address the areas not yet completed. An Extension Application was submitted October 2008 and approved.

Year 5

In December 2008 an extension was approved to June 2010 to complete the remaining tasks of the original project. In summary the extension was to allow time and funding to finalise the best options for control of powdery mildew, silverleaf whitefly (SLWF), viruses and weed management, based on the significant number of trials undertaken during the project period. The best options were to be communicated to extension officers and growers through an extension workshop and a grower's manual. Due to staffing changes these objectives were not fully achieved and, following end-of-project review in April 2010, the project has been extended to December 2010 to allow a final season for communicating the outcomes to the industry stakeholders. The project has now achieved many of the intended milestones and outcomes, and in the final 9-month extension, commercial recommendations will be disseminated as updated extension leaflets, with a farm demonstration field day in September 2010, and will include economic analysis of these recommendation to ensure they are not only effective but also cost-effective.
a. Powdery Mildew
Based on three years of trials, the results have demonstrated that it is a) important to alternate class of fungicide during the season to avoid resistance buildup of powdery mildew populations, b) it is possible to replace one or two hard fungicide (e.g. triazole) applications with GRAS options such as stylet oil or sulphur, c) systemic acquired resistance (SAR) may be useful as a seed treatment before sowing to obtain resistance throughout the plant. An extension workshop was held with farmers in February 2010 on safe use of pesticides and leaflets handed out on powdery mildew control in squash.
b. Weeds Project
Use of Mucuna during the fallow season has been very successful in suppressing weeds in the following squash season. An extension workshop was held with farmers in Feb 2010 on use of Mucuna to reduce weed problems. Extension material consisted of audio visual material as well as posters and leaflets. In the west of the island Mucuna has been adopted by one large squash grower which has had positive influence on others taking up the new intervention. The advantages of using Mucuna are: a) farmers are able to commence land preparation a later in May, b) it is easier to cultivate land compared to the vigorous grass weeds, c) there are less weeds in the squash crop, d) Mucuna adds nitrogen and organic matter to the soil, e) there is some evidence that Mucuna assists in the release of phosphorous, bound in the soil.
c. SLWF
SLWF has not been a great problem during the life of the project and therefore conclusions on the use of pesticides that complement IPM practices have not been confirmed. SLWF affects tomato crops in April-August and then moves across to squash. There were two releases of the parasitoid Eretmocerus hayatii; however heavy rain prevented the buildup of natural populations. This season, scouting will confirm whether the parasitoid is present or whether re-introduction is necessary.
d. Virology
It was confirmed that the following weeds tested as hosts for the following viruses: a) Synedrella nodiflora - positive for ZYMV & PRSV, b) Commelina benghalensis - positive for CMV, c) Commelina grandis - positive for PRSV, d) Malvastrium coromandelianum - positive for ZYMV and PRSV. The main vector identified was Aphis gossipii. No evidence of seed transmission was found. Recommended control of viruses in squash involves use of field hygiene such removal of field debris plus control of insect vectors.
Capacity building activities have included training through the John Allwright Fellowship Scheme.

Location

There are no project locations defined for this project.