Main Menu
Impact of water saving irrigation techniques in China
Project ID
LWR1/1998/066
Project Country
Commissioned Organisation
International Water Management Institute, Sri Lanka
Project Leader
Dr To Phuc Tuong
T.Tuong@cgiar.org
Phone:
632 812 7686 ext 732
Fax:
632 891-1292
Project Budget
$148,412.00
Start Date
01/01/1999
Finish Date
31/12/2000
ACIAR Research Program Manager
Dr Ian Willett
Overview Objectives
The main aim was to develop new, readily-implemented irrigation strategies for rice-growing systems to improve water efficiency, without losing productivity or cost-effectiveness.
Project Background and Objectives
In Asia, demand for water is growing rapidly, with little potential for increasing the supply. As the region develops, more and more water is being diverted to non-agricultural uses. But at the same time the demand for food is growing and rice, the staple crop, needs irrigation water.
In China, shortage of water (rather than of land) is the biggest constraint to agriculture. Irrigation has played a vital role in keeping the pace of growth in rice production aligned with growth of the population. Currently, 96 per cent of the annual rice production of 130.6 million tonnes comes from irrigated systems. In the future rice production in China will need to double while water throughout the country will be in increasing short supply. Per capita freshwater availability, already among the lowest in Asia, is declining. Therefore saving water in rice-based irrigation systems deserves more attention. In essence, the country needs to produce more rice with less water.
The Chinese government has already pioneered water-saving irrigation (WSI) techniques to help achieve greater water efficiency in rice-based farming systems. The techniques, aimed mainly at reducing seepage and percolation from farms, have been widely adopted in China. However, several scientific issues need to be better understood before going any further with the development and implementation of WSI practices. For example, does the drier soil in WSI lead to water stress in rice plants during their reproductive phase? Is the efficiency of nitrogen uptake altered? Are there any effects on the population dynamics of weeds?
This project attempted to answer some of these questions and to address broader technical issues underlying the successful application of WSI.
Progress Reports (Year 1, 2, 3 etc)
Year 1:
The demand for water in Asia is expected to increase by 50 percent over the next 20 years. To avoid the serious crisis of the looming water crisis for food security and to make more water available for the non-agricultural sector, there is an urgent need to develop and promote ways to increase water use efficiency in agriculture.
Since 50 percent of the irrigated area in Asia is planted to rice, saving water in rice-based irrigation systems deserves particular attention. In this context. and within the framework of the System-Wide Initiative on Water Management (SWIM), scientists from International Water Management Institute (lWMI) and International Rice Research Institute (IRRI) are collaborating with NARS to find ways to produce "more rice with less water".
The water shortage is being felt more urgently in China than in many other Asian countries. Recognizing the severity of the situation. China has pioneered some water saving irrigation (WSI) techniques aimed at reducing seepage and percolation at the farm level. These techniques are being widely adopted in different parts of China. However, there are a number of important, unanswered questions:
What has been the impact of WSI and other factors on water saving?
Has the introduction of WSI at farm level led to water saving in the basin?
Can WSI as practised in China be extended and successfully practised in other locations?
The focus of this study is on the first two questions.
The objective of this research is to address the technical issues underlying the successful application of WSI. These include:
(i) Quantifying the impact of WSI on water saving, rice crop yields, and fertilizer use efficiency.
(ii) Assessing the financial costs and benefits to farmers who are using these technologies, and
(iii) Identifying irrigation system and basin-wide impacts of on-farm WSI innovations in order to understand the degree to which large scale adoption of WSI will lead to system and basin-wide water savings and water productivity increases.
The research team includes scientists from IWMI, IRRI, Wuhan University of Hydraulic and Electrical Engineering (WUHEE), and Zhejiang Agricultural University (ZAU) each of which brings different strengths to address the above objectives. Through frequent field visits, meetings, and exchange of information the research team has built a strong sense of purpose and high esprit de corp.
The research has been organized around four subprojects. Sub-project 1 involves the conduct of experiments on stations in Zhanghe in Hubei Province and Jinhua in Zhejiang Province. The experimental design included treatments with and without WSI with different timing of fertiliser application. Sub-project 2 focuses on the financial assessments of WSI. A survey of 30 farms has been conducted in each of two sites in Zhanghe Irrigation District, one with and one without the adoption of WSI management Techniques. Sub-project 3 focuses on assessing the impact of WSI on water productivity, at different scales. In the same sites (with and without WSI) covered by the farm survey, water accounting studies are being conducted at the farm level and in a much larger service area with measurements taken twice daily of water inflows and outflows during the rice growing season. Sub-project 4, a seminar to be held at the end of the project will discuss the project outcomes among Chinese and international water scientists. In addition to the above sub-projects, data has been gathered on long-term trends in water allocation among sectors and rice crop yields in order to assess the factors contributing to the increase in land and water productivity over time.
Most of the first year's data is still being analysed. However, results from analysis of long-term trends in water allocation and of the first year's experiments provide some interesting results. From 1966 to 1998, despite a decline in water allocation to agriculture of 60 percent and a decline in rice area irrigated by 15 percent, total rice production has increased. This has been made possible by an almost doubling of rice yield per hectare and quadrupling of rice yield per cubic meter of water. The trends in growth in rice yield per hectare in Zhanghe District are very similar to those for Hubei and for all of China and the factor contributing to this trend reasonably well understood. The next step is to attempt to identify the contribution of factors (other than increase in yield per hectare) including WSI to the increase in the productivity of water, using the trend data, our field research results and other sources of information
Results of the first year's experiments conducted at Tuanlin Station in Zhanghe District showed yield per hectare to be somewhat lower for WSI treatments than for the normal flooding practice contrary to what is normally reported by Chinese researchers. Yields per unit of water were slightly higher, but again the level of water saving was much less than we anticipated based on other reports. We have not yet analysed the rainfall pattern for this year as compared to other years to determine how this may have affected our results.
We find a growing interest in WSI outside of China. We have discovered the practice of alternate wetting and drying in paddy rice production being practised in a number of locations. With the growing shortage of water, it is extremely important to identify the potential of WSI and related practices such as volumetric pricing of water under different situations. With the submission of this report we have also prepared a concept proposal for a follow-on study that will allow us to assess the potential of WSI under a wider range of conditions.
Project Outcomes
As the research progressed, the decision was made to focus on alternate wetting and drying (AWD) irrigation, a WSI technique that is being popularised in China. Also, it was found essential to obtain detailed information on institutions and on the management of water resources in the Zhanghe Irrigation System (ZIS) system, including the change in allocation of water between irrigation and other sectors over time. In short, researchers concluded that it was impossible to separate technical and biophysical issues from management and socioeconomic issues.
Results of both the experiments and farm surveys showed that there was no difference in yields between AWD and conventional shallow-flooded irrigation practices. However, there were gains in water productivity. Both experimental and farmers' monitoring confirmed that AWD tended to use less irrigation water. Mid-season drainage and intermittent soil drying were not prerequisites for high yield. Thus in years with high rainfall, farmers do not have to drain out rainwater to achieve soil drying, and therefore can conserve more water. There was no significant water x nutrient interaction on grain yields, biomass and nitrogen (N) uptake. Thus AWD does not require a different N-fertiliser management regime from continuous flooding.
Two townships were surveyed. The township where farmers practiced less AWD had higher water use and higher cost of irrigation per farm. However, AWD was practiced much more widely in the dry year (2000) than in the wet year (1999). It is thus difficult to determine whether farmers are voluntarily accepting AWD or being forced to practice AWD due to reduced deliveries in the system.
In subproject 3 the researchers tested a water accounting methodology to study irrigation system and basin-wide implications of on-farm AWD. They found that, in addition to micro and mezzo scales, even larger scales were needed to better understand the degree to which water savings were achieved at the system and basin levels.
A prerequisite for AWD is a reliable supply system. This is achieved in ZIS by a combination of system management, institutional arrangement, and infrastructure. The infrastructure includes numerous small ponds and reservoirs permitting storage and control of water releases near the farm. Also important is the volumetric pricing of water at the village level, providing incentive for the farmers to reduce irrigation costs by using less water.
This combination of factors has permitted the ZIS to divert water to higher-valued uses. The amount of water supplied for irrigation from the main reservoir has dropped from 80 to 25 per cent of its volume over the past 25 years. However, this combination of factors is not readily found in other developing countries, and researchers should be cautious about the applicability of these findings in other regions.
Location
There are no project locations defined for this project.
