Main Menu
Remediation and management of degraded earthen shrimp ponds in Indonesia and Australia
Project ID
FIS/1997/022
Project Country
Commissioned Organisation
University of New South Wales, Australia
Project Leader
Dr Jesmond Sammut
j.sammut@unsw.edu.au
Phone:
02 9385 8281
Fax:
02 9385 1558
Project Budget
$851,129.00
Start Date
01/07/1998
Finish Date
30/06/2001
Extension Start Date
01/07/2001
Extension Finish Date
30/06/2005
ACIAR Research Program Manager
Mr Barney Smith
Overview Objectives
The project aimed to develop and assess cost-effective, low technology methods of treating and managing soil acidification associated with the disturbance of ASS. It also tested low-cost technology, settlement ponds and vegetation planting to ameliorate and conserve soils on pond walls and bottoms, and in effluent canals. Another focus was the accumulation of iron in pond sediments and development of strategies to minimise iron leaching from the soil and its deposition in intensive ponds.
Project Background and Objectives
Until recently problems of production in shrimp farms of the Asia Pacific region have been linked to disease and farm management practices. There was little understanding of the effect of acid sulfate soils (ASS) on pond productivity. An earlier ACIAR study in Indonesia, Philippines, India and Australia found a link between ASS and disease in wild and pond-cultured aquatic animals, so severe in some circumstances that shrimp ponds were abandoned.
This has been the case in India and now in Indonesia, where many small farm owners, particularly in rural areas and transmigration zones had turned to shrimp farming in place of traditional agriculture. The failure of shrimp ponds in these systems has led to reduced land value, economic hardship, altered social structure, lower standards of living and long-term environmental degradation. The problems faced on acid sulfate soils in Indonesia were considered so large that urgent research was needed. Research on sediment accumulation and soil erosion were also critical to more effective shrimp farming in Australia, especially in light of the need to comply with strict environmental guidelines in order to gain and retain an aquaculture licence.
Progress Reports (Year 1, 2, 3 etc)
Year 1:
Year 4 (01/07/2001-30/06/2002)
The project scientists have developed methods to remediate and manage shrimp ponds degraded by acid and metal contamination associated with acid sulfate soils and to minimise the effects of soil erosion through pond soil conservation strategies. Hydrogeochemical studies of dyke and pond soils in Australia and Indonesia have described, in detail, the processes that cause pond degradation. The studies found that dyke soils are a major contributor of acid and metals, due to their capacity to generate large amounts of proton and mineral acidity through pyrite oxidation and metal hydrolysis respectively.
Field and laboratory-based studies, as well as hydrogeochemical modelling, were used to calculate more effective lime application rates for commonly used soil types and varying levels of existing acidity and acid producing potential. Liming strategies were developed in combination with pond preparation methods such as fertilisation, drying and flushing. Different types of commercially available lime and modified application strategies were tested for their efficacy, firstly under laboratory conditions and then in the field through a complete production period.
Rapid bioassays and toxicological studies tested the survival of shrimp exposed to leachate from treated soil. Treated pond soil leachate and effluent were monitored and assessed to prevent offsite pollution and toxicity to the farmed shrimp. The study showed that the integration of lime into dyke soil materials was more effective than the standard method of liming the first 10 cm of surface sediments. Where reconstruction of dykes is not possible, the liming and pond preparation strategies developed under the program nevertheless created significant improvements in pond production. The efficacy of lime was increased by using fine-grained lime and when possible applying additional lime in a slurry to avoid loss by wind erosion and to improve seepage into the soil. Slurry mixtures also reduce micro encapsulation of lime granules, improve solubility and reduce loss by wind action.
Survival rates of up to 90% were achieved in formerly abandoned and low-yielding ponds. Improved liming and pond preparation strategies reduced soil pH and associated metal contamination of pond waters, increased survival and growth rates in shrimp and improved the density of beneficial algal blooms. By contrast, ponds treated by standard practices produced lower yields, experienced significant problems with metal contamination, and the depletion of phosphate which is scavenged by metals in the pond soils.
Three alternative farming systems were trialled for severely degraded ponds in Indonesia. Juvenile shrimp production in net enclosures provides a low risk alternative to monoculture. Production periods are limited to 21 days to manage risk associated with fluxes of acid and metals. Juvenile shrimp are a profitable alternative to complete monoculture growout because of the demand for juvenile shrimp by farmers operating ponds unaffected by acid sulfate soils. Net enclosures improved disease management and harvest, and also enabled farmers to move stock during period of poor water quality. Milkfish (Chanos chanos) and seaweed (Gracilaria verrucosa) culture were found to be sustainable alternatives to more risky shrimp monoculture (full growout) due to their higher tolerance to acid and metals.
Simple field techniques to identify acid sulfate soils were developed based on biological, physical and production indicators. A brochure and poster outlining field assessment methods were developed to assist farmers. Improved site selection criteria that address acid sulfate soil assessment were developed to enable farmers, extension officers and consultants to evaluate the suitability of sites for new ponds. GIS and Remote Sensing techniques, soil assessment and geomorphology were used to develop protocols for land capability assessment to map and classify land to assist environmental decision making in aquaculture development programs.
Year 2:
Year 4 (01/07/2001-30/06/2002)
The project scientists have developed methods to remediate and manage shrimp ponds degraded by acid and metal contamination associated with acid sulfate soils and to minimise the effects of soil erosion through pond soil conservation strategies. Hydrogeochemical studies of dyke and pond soils in Australia and Indonesia have described, in detail, the processes that cause pond degradation. The studies found that dyke soils are a major contributor of acid and metals, due to their capacity to generate large amounts of proton and mineral acidity through pyrite oxidation and metal hydrolysis respectively.
Field and laboratory-based studies, as well as hydrogeochemical modelling, were used to calculate more effective lime application rates for commonly used soil types and varying levels of existing acidity and acid producing potential. Liming strategies were developed in combination with pond preparation methods such as fertilisation, drying and flushing. Different types of commercially available lime and modified application strategies were tested for their efficacy, firstly under laboratory conditions and then in the field through a complete production period.
Rapid bioassays and toxicological studies tested the survival of shrimp exposed to leachate from treated soil. Treated pond soil leachate and effluent were monitored and assessed to prevent offsite pollution and toxicity to the farmed shrimp. The study showed that the integration of lime into dyke soil materials was more effective than the standard method of liming the first 10 cm of surface sediments. Where reconstruction of dykes is not possible, the liming and pond preparation strategies developed under the program nevertheless created significant improvements in pond production. The efficacy of lime was increased by using fine-grained lime and when possible applying additional lime in a slurry to avoid loss by wind erosion and to improve seepage into the soil. Slurry mixtures also reduce micro encapsulation of lime granules, improve solubility and reduce loss by wind action.
Survival rates of up to 90% were achieved in formerly abandoned and low-yielding ponds. Improved liming and pond preparation strategies reduced soil pH and associated metal contamination of pond waters, increased survival and growth rates in shrimp and improved the density of beneficial algal blooms. By contrast, ponds treated by standard practices produced lower yields, experienced significant problems with metal contamination, and the depletion of phosphate which is scavenged by metals in the pond soils.
Three alternative farming systems were trialled for severely degraded ponds in Indonesia. Juvenile shrimp production in net enclosures provides a low risk alternative to monoculture. Production periods are limited to 21 days to manage risk associated with fluxes of acid and metals. Juvenile shrimp are a profitable alternative to complete monoculture growout because of the demand for juvenile shrimp by farmers operating ponds unaffected by acid sulfate soils. Net enclosures improved disease management and harvest, and also enabled farmers to move stock during period of poor water quality. Milkfish (Chanos chanos) and seaweed (Gracilaria verrucosa) culture were found to be sustainable alternatives to more risky shrimp monoculture (full growout) due to their higher tolerance to acid and metals.
Simple field techniques to identify acid sulfate soils were developed based on biological, physical and production indicators. A brochure and poster outlining field assessment methods were developed to assist farmers. Improved site selection criteria that address acid sulfate soil assessment were developed to enable farmers, extension officers and consultants to evaluate the suitability of sites for new ponds. GIS and Remote Sensing techniques, soil assessment and geomorphology were used to develop protocols for land capability assessment to map and classify land to assist environmental decision making in aquaculture development programs.
Year 3:
Year 4 (01/07/2001-30/06/2002)
The project scientists have developed methods to remediate and manage shrimp ponds degraded by acid and metal contamination associated with acid sulfate soils and to minimise the effects of soil erosion through pond soil conservation strategies. Hydrogeochemical studies of dyke and pond soils in Australia and Indonesia have described, in detail, the processes that cause pond degradation. The studies found that dyke soils are a major contributor of acid and metals, due to their capacity to generate large amounts of proton and mineral acidity through pyrite oxidation and metal hydrolysis respectively.
Field and laboratory-based studies, as well as hydrogeochemical modelling, were used to calculate more effective lime application rates for commonly used soil types and varying levels of existing acidity and acid producing potential. Liming strategies were developed in combination with pond preparation methods such as fertilisation, drying and flushing. Different types of commercially available lime and modified application strategies were tested for their efficacy, firstly under laboratory conditions and then in the field through a complete production period.
Rapid bioassays and toxicological studies tested the survival of shrimp exposed to leachate from treated soil. Treated pond soil leachate and effluent were monitored and assessed to prevent offsite pollution and toxicity to the farmed shrimp. The study showed that the integration of lime into dyke soil materials was more effective than the standard method of liming the first 10 cm of surface sediments. Where reconstruction of dykes is not possible, the liming and pond preparation strategies developed under the program nevertheless created significant improvements in pond production. The efficacy of lime was increased by using fine-grained lime and when possible applying additional lime in a slurry to avoid loss by wind erosion and to improve seepage into the soil. Slurry mixtures also reduce micro encapsulation of lime granules, improve solubility and reduce loss by wind action.
Survival rates of up to 90% were achieved in formerly abandoned and low-yielding ponds. Improved liming and pond preparation strategies reduced soil pH and associated metal contamination of pond waters, increased survival and growth rates in shrimp and improved the density of beneficial algal blooms. By contrast, ponds treated by standard practices produced lower yields, experienced significant problems with metal contamination, and the depletion of phosphate which is scavenged by metals in the pond soils.
Three alternative farming systems were trialled for severely degraded ponds in Indonesia. Juvenile shrimp production in net enclosures provides a low risk alternative to monoculture. Production periods are limited to 21 days to manage risk associated with fluxes of acid and metals. Juvenile shrimp are a profitable alternative to complete monoculture growout because of the demand for juvenile shrimp by farmers operating ponds unaffected by acid sulfate soils. Net enclosures improved disease management and harvest, and also enabled farmers to move stock during period of poor water quality. Milkfish (Chanos chanos) and seaweed (Gracilaria verrucosa) culture were found to be sustainable alternatives to more risky shrimp monoculture (full growout) due to their higher tolerance to acid and metals.
Simple field techniques to identify acid sulfate soils were developed based on biological, physical and production indicators. A brochure and poster outlining field assessment methods were developed to assist farmers. Improved site selection criteria that address acid sulfate soil assessment were developed to enable farmers, extension officers and consultants to evaluate the suitability of sites for new ponds. GIS and Remote Sensing techniques, soil assessment and geomorphology were used to develop protocols for land capability assessment to map and classify land to assist environmental decision making in aquaculture development programs.
Year 4:
Year 4 (01/07/2001-30/06/2002)
The project scientists have developed methods to remediate and manage shrimp ponds degraded by acid and metal contamination associated with acid sulfate soils and to minimise the effects of soil erosion through pond soil conservation strategies. Hydrogeochemical studies of dyke and pond soils in Australia and Indonesia have described, in detail, the processes that cause pond degradation. The studies found that dyke soils are a major contributor of acid and metals, due to their capacity to generate large amounts of proton and mineral acidity through pyrite oxidation and metal hydrolysis respectively.
Field and laboratory-based studies, as well as hydrogeochemical modelling, were used to calculate more effective lime application rates for commonly used soil types and varying levels of existing acidity and acid producing potential. Liming strategies were developed in combination with pond preparation methods such as fertilisation, drying and flushing. Different types of commercially available lime and modified application strategies were tested for their efficacy, firstly under laboratory conditions and then in the field through a complete production period.
Rapid bioassays and toxicological studies tested the survival of shrimp exposed to leachate from treated soil. Treated pond soil leachate and effluent were monitored and assessed to prevent offsite pollution and toxicity to the farmed shrimp. The study showed that the integration of lime into dyke soil materials was more effective than the standard method of liming the first 10 cm of surface sediments. Where reconstruction of dykes is not possible, the liming and pond preparation strategies developed under the program nevertheless created significant improvements in pond production. The efficacy of lime was increased by using fine-grained lime and when possible applying additional lime in a slurry to avoid loss by wind erosion and to improve seepage into the soil. Slurry mixtures also reduce micro encapsulation of lime granules, improve solubility and reduce loss by wind action.
Survival rates of up to 90% were achieved in formerly abandoned and low-yielding ponds. Improved liming and pond preparation strategies reduced soil pH and associated metal contamination of pond waters, increased survival and growth rates in shrimp and improved the density of beneficial algal blooms. By contrast, ponds treated by standard practices produced lower yields, experienced significant problems with metal contamination, and the depletion of phosphate which is scavenged by metals in the pond soils.
Three alternative farming systems were trialled for severely degraded ponds in Indonesia. Juvenile shrimp production in net enclosures provides a low risk alternative to monoculture. Production periods are limited to 21 days to manage risk associated with fluxes of acid and metals. Juvenile shrimp are a profitable alternative to complete monoculture growout because of the demand for juvenile shrimp by farmers operating ponds unaffected by acid sulfate soils. Net enclosures improved disease management and harvest, and also enabled farmers to move stock during period of poor water quality. Milkfish (Chanos chanos) and seaweed (Gracilaria verrucosa) culture were found to be sustainable alternatives to more risky shrimp monoculture (full growout) due to their higher tolerance to acid and metals.
Simple field techniques to identify acid sulfate soils were developed based on biological, physical and production indicators. A brochure and poster outlining field assessment methods were developed to assist farmers. Improved site selection criteria that address acid sulfate soil assessment were developed to enable farmers, extension officers and consultants to evaluate the suitability of sites for new ponds. GIS and Remote Sensing techniques, soil assessment and geomorphology were used to develop protocols for land capability assessment to map and classify land to assist environmental decision making in aquaculture development programs.
Project Outcomes
The project produced an immense amount of valuable information for the shrimp industry as well as for resource and environmental planning in Indonesia and Australia. Major outcomes included description of the chemical and physical processes leading to ASS problems, and development of methods to identify ASS in the field and laboratory to assist in site selection for shrimp ponds.
Other advances included the development of strategies for dyke construction, lime use and water management for ameliorating and minimising the effects of ASS in shrimp ponds. Alternative farming systems were trialled for ponds severely affected by ASS, including use of net enclosures for juvenile shrimp production, and culture of milkfish and seaweed. Different types of acid- and salt-tolerant vegetation were tested to determine their effectiveness against erosion from rill, splash, wind and wave. The vegetation was found to decrease the likelihood of erosion and reduce the levels of erosion in water and the erodability of pond soils.
Pond construction was investigated, including pond wall stability under different slopes, dyke heights and widths for the common soil types, lining materials and water management to prevent soil erosion. To determine the extent of the ASS and as a guide to future planning of coastal shrimp aquaculture the scientists employed geographic information systems, remote sensing techniques and soil assessment to map and classify ASS across South and Southeast Sulawesi.
Data sharing with other agencies led to the redesign of a large irrigation system based on soil mapping and characteristics. Before the redesign the system was planned to run through a large area of ASS.
Location
There are no project locations defined for this project.
