Main Menu
Developing disease management capacity in Vietnam
Project ID
CP/1999/007
Project Country
Commissioned Organisation
CAB International, Plant Pathology, UK
Project Leader
Dr Mark Holderness
m.holderness@cabi.org
Phone:
44 0 1491 829043
Fax:
44 0 149 829100
Project Budget
$773,916.00
Start Date
01/01/2001
Finish Date
31/12/2003
Extension Start Date
01/01/2004
Extension Finish Date
30/06/2004
ACIAR Research Program Manager
Dr T K Lim
Overview Objectives
Project objectives were: to establish regional disease research networks and develop disease diagnostic and research capacity among young scientists; to develop a database and manual of horticultural crop diseases; to support young scientists to develop appropriate management strategies; to initiate prioritised research programs for improved understanding of pathogen biology and ecology of known and new diseases.
Project Background and Objectives
Vietnam has experienced diseases in perennial fruit crops, some industrial crops and vegetables, but until now has had little ability to cope with the problems. This project was designed to increase the plant pathology research skills and plant disease management skills of Vietnamese scientists. It achieved this through training programs, improved access to information, advice on development of research programs and operation of practical research programs in a number of crops and commodities of increasing importance to Vietnam. Crops included perennial fruits planted to rehabilitate degraded lands (and to provide incomes for poor farmers in mountain regions), plus industrial crops such as sugar, coffee, tea and cocoa. Vegetables were also included in some areas to assist Vietnam's national vegetable integrated pest management program.
The project featured strong involvement of researchers working with farmers and extension workers in all the practical projects. Attention was given to building linkages between the various institutions working on these problems throughout Vietnam - such linkages are unusual in Vietnam, and their inclusion was designed to ensure better collaboration through improved efficiency and synergy.
Progress Reports (Year 1, 2, 3 etc)
Year 1:
1 PROGRESS SUMMARY
The project addresses a number of inter-related themes in developing capacity in plant health across a range of Vietnamese research and extension institutions. By directly linking young scientists from different institutions it creates sustainable processes and activities that integrate and make best use of the different capabilities involved. The project emphasizes direct engagement with farmers through participatory learning mechanisms.
1 Regional disease research networks established and disease diagnostic and research capacity developed among young scientists. Up to now, over 100 young scientists have been trained in pathogen identification techniques by staff from CABI Bioscience and QPDI. Training material has been collated into a manual 'Laboratory Techniques for Plant Health Diagnostics'. Translation into Vietnamese is on-going.
Strong regional networks have been established, coordinating survey work and implementing participatory research activities. In the North, institutional learning and impact of the methods used to control anthracnose in longan and litchi is being compared by Hanoi Agricultural University, Thai Nguyen Agricultural University and NIPP. In Can Tho province, mango anthracnose and black spot are addressed by staff from SOFRI and Cantho University, illustrating improved collaboration between institutes. In Tien Giang province, the project is linking joined activities by SOFRI and PHTI with an on-going AusAID-CARD project, increasing the impact of research by linking to farmer cooperatives.
2 Database and manual of horticultural crop diseases developed. During earlier surveys, some fundamental issues arose regarding the way in which the disease status of horticultural crops is assessed. The project highlighted that, when moving away from the main crop-main diseases situation, young scientists can face real problems in diagnosing crop health problems in the field.
This experience has significant implication for future projects. When designing projects related to crop and tree health, an important first step should be to ensure that the real issues are being addressed, by training project staff in field diagnostics, before embarking on survey work. In this way, accuracy and value of the results will increase tremendously.
Alongside the schematic and very comprehensive compilation of our survey data, project staff from QDPI have over the past year concentrated on improving local capacity with regard to sample collection techniques and identification of pathogens for which symptoms had been indicated as of uncertain origin. QDPI are also summarizing a list of pathogens identified by other ACIAR projects in Vietnam. This on-going activity is one of the project's strengths: integration of existing information across projects and institutes and making previous work more accessible to Vietnamese stakeholders.
The manual of horticultural crop disease management will be developed during the third year of our project, integrating the information gathered by the project with that generated through farmer participatory research (FPR) activities on disease management.
3 Support young scientists to develop appropriate management strategies. Historically, science is often portrayed as the driving force in generating technologies, with the extension system delivering these technologies to the farming community. Failures in adoption of new technologies are blamed on the inadequacy of extension systems or the farmers' resistance to change. Our project has moved away from this paradigm, and is training young scientists in new methodologies to conduct research with, rather than for, farmers.
Developing appropriate management strategies is currently being addressed through FPR, and focuses on major diseases in mango (anthracnose and bacterial black spot), longan and litchi (anthracnose), pineapple (Phytophthora heart rot and mealybug wilt virus), citrus (greening), chili (anthracnose) and tomato (bacterial wilt).
Management topics are prioritized as either dealing with newly-emerging severe problems in Vietnam (pineapple mealybug wilt and mango black spot), or well-established pathogens for which management options may be inappropriate to farmers' circumstances (anthracnose, bacterial wilt and greening).
4 Initiate prioritized research programmes for improved understanding of pathogen biology and ecology of known and new diseases. Following the above, requirements for future research on the biology and ecology of targeted diseases will be facilitated through cross-linkages between different institutions and programs.
Very little information is available on witches' broom on longan and diseases of dragon fruit, identified as a target export crop in the beginning of the project. This will be addressed in the next year.
Upon request of the Ministry, the project identified pineapple wilt disease prevalent in both North and South Vietnam. The disease is caused by a virus transmitted by mealybugs. Different names have been assigned to the disease by farmers surveyed, ranging from leaf blast, wilt disease, red leaves to red wilt. This example further emphasizes the need for a more holistic approach in diagnosing plant health problems. Knowledge of insect vectors becomes equally important.
Year 2:
1 PROGRESS SUMMARY
The project addresses a number of inter-related themes in developing capacity in plant health across a range of Vietnamese research and extension institutions. By directly linking young scientists from different institutions it creates sustainable processes and activities that integrate and make best use of the different capabilities involved. The project emphasizes direct engagement with farmers through participatory learning mechanisms.
1 Regional disease research networks established and disease diagnostic and research capacity developed among young scientists. Up to now, over 100 young scientists have been trained in pathogen identification techniques by staff from CABI Bioscience and QPDI. Training material has been collated into a manual 'Laboratory Techniques for Plant Health Diagnostics'. Translation into Vietnamese is on-going.
Strong regional networks have been established, coordinating survey work and implementing participatory research activities. In the North, institutional learning and impact of the methods used to control anthracnose in longan and litchi is being compared by Hanoi Agricultural University, Thai Nguyen Agricultural University and NIPP. In Can Tho province, mango anthracnose and black spot are addressed by staff from SOFRI and Cantho University, illustrating improved collaboration between institutes. In Tien Giang province, the project is linking joined activities by SOFRI and PHTI with an on-going AusAID-CARD project, increasing the impact of research by linking to farmer cooperatives.
2 Database and manual of horticultural crop diseases developed. During earlier surveys, some fundamental issues arose regarding the way in which the disease status of horticultural crops is assessed. The project highlighted that, when moving away from the main crop-main diseases situation, young scientists can face real problems in diagnosing crop health problems in the field.
This experience has significant implication for future projects. When designing projects related to crop and tree health, an important first step should be to ensure that the real issues are being addressed, by training project staff in field diagnostics, before embarking on survey work. In this way, accuracy and value of the results will increase tremendously.
Alongside the schematic and very comprehensive compilation of our survey data, project staff from QDPI have over the past year concentrated on improving local capacity with regard to sample collection techniques and identification of pathogens for which symptoms had been indicated as of uncertain origin. QDPI are also summarizing a list of pathogens identified by other ACIAR projects in Vietnam. This on-going activity is one of the project's strengths: integration of existing information across projects and institutes and making previous work more accessible to Vietnamese stakeholders.
The manual of horticultural crop disease management will be developed during the third year of our project, integrating the information gathered by the project with that generated through farmer participatory research (FPR) activities on disease management.
3 Support young scientists to develop appropriate management strategies. Historically, science is often portrayed as the driving force in generating technologies, with the extension system delivering these technologies to the farming community. Failures in adoption of new technologies are blamed on the inadequacy of extension systems or the farmers' resistance to change. Our project has moved away from this paradigm, and is training young scientists in new methodologies to conduct research with, rather than for, farmers.
Developing appropriate management strategies is currently being addressed through FPR, and focuses on major diseases in mango (anthracnose and bacterial black spot), longan and litchi (anthracnose), pineapple (Phytophthora heart rot and mealybug wilt virus), citrus (greening), chili (anthracnose) and tomato (bacterial wilt).
Management topics are prioritized as either dealing with newly-emerging severe problems in Vietnam (pineapple mealybug wilt and mango black spot), or well-established pathogens for which management options may be inappropriate to farmers' circumstances (anthracnose, bacterial wilt and greening).
4 Initiate prioritized research programmes for improved understanding of pathogen biology and ecology of known and new diseases. Following the above, requirements for future research on the biology and ecology of targeted diseases will be facilitated through cross-linkages between different institutions and programs.
Very little information is available on witches' broom on longan and diseases of dragon fruit, identified as a target export crop in the beginning of the project. This will be addressed in the next year.
Upon request of the Ministry, the project identified pineapple wilt disease prevalent in both North and South Vietnam. The disease is caused by a virus transmitted by mealybugs. Different names have been assigned to the disease by farmers surveyed, ranging from leaf blast, wilt disease, red leaves to red wilt. This example further emphasizes the need for a more holistic approach in diagnosing plant health problems. Knowledge of insect vectors becomes equally important.
Project Outcomes
The topics addressed by the project team in tackling the development of capacity in disease management and plant health were wide ranging. They included new methods for linking research to extension, and combined improving skills in the laboratory with major improvements in field science and diagnostics.
The project trained more than 250 young scientists and extension workers in 17 courses and workshops. Plant health diagnosis in both field and laboratory was a major focus, and has resulted in observable improvements in how diseases are recorded and information is passed both from field to institutes (a vital link in delivering improved quarantine intelligence) and from laboratory to field (an equally vital link for more effective management of diseases).
Customised training materials were developed to support the training efforts. These included a manual on 'Laboratory techniques for plant health diagnostics' (mostly laboratory based) and the first trainers' manual on 'Plant health diagnostics in the field'. This manual instructs and guides local trainers on how to deliver the course within Vietnam under a proposed national program aimed at increasing the capacity of extension workers, The focus on symptom-based diagnostics was crucial in changing the mindset of scientists and extension officers towards disease management in the field.
One of the partners (SOFRI) has begun a new initiative to prepare 12 Vietnamese trainingn modules with handouts, flip charts and Powerpoint presentations based on the project activities, which will be used to train the next generation of extension officers. The project laid the ground for an integrated approach to plant health management, but institutional changes need to be maintained and progress consolidated.
The project has resulted in a range of methods and tools for doing research on diseases that include the biology and ecology of pathogens, farmer participatory research on IPM, linking research to extension, and analysing local knowledge of diseases. These methods and tools have been tested and validated for Vietnam, providing a model for other countries seeking to build capacity.
When doing surveys of the disease status of horticultural crops, it is critical to first ensure that the real issues are being addressed and appropriate training in field diagnostics is provided before embarking on the survey work.
The project produced a comprehensive compilation of survey data. As part of the project, staff of the Queensland Department of Primary Industries and Fisheries collated and summarised pathogens and diseases identified by related ACIAR projects in Vietnam, a valuable step in making project outputs more widely available.
The project helped broaden young scientists' understanding by demonstrating what can be learned from how farmers approach disease management, and the benefits of collaborative research with farmers. The Going Public method (a simple yet effective method for interacting with farmers that is quick and cheap) was introduced and tested in public places such as markets, to show, gather and share information with farmers.
Participatory research was undertaken on newly emerging problems in Vietnam that are having a devastating impact on farmers' incomes (pineapple mealybug wilt and dragon fruit branch rot), and on established, well-know pathogens that lacked appropriate management options (eg litchi and chilli anthracnose, tomato bacterial wilt, citrus huanglongbing). Treatments varied from use of organic fertiliser to sanitary pruning, vector control and use of fungicides. The control strategies developed were informed by farmer knowledge and practical constraints in the field.
Project work done by the various institutes on key diseases of priority crops has been made available in separate technical reports.
Location
There are no project locations defined for this project.
